It’s A Wonderful Life: A Retrospective Film Review

It was the great American poet Walt Whitman whom Frank Capra quotes, when talking about the inspiration for his celebrated classic It’s A Wonderful Life (1946). The line, from the poem A Song for Occupations reads;

“The sum of all known reverences I add up in you, whoever you are ..”

Walt Whitman

What a sentiment! It would be prudent to note that Capra’s own philosophy of film-making and indeed life, is summed up in the film and ergo, this line of prose.

American poet Walt Whitman (1819 – 1892)

Frank Capra was a little out of practice at making big budget crowd-pleasers by the time he came to make It’s a Wonderful Life. Based on the novel ‘The Greatest Gift’ by Philip Van Doren Stern and filmed in 1946, it was to be Capra’s tentative re-entry into Hollywood after documenting events, to great acclaim, in WWII. The Second World War had taken many men away, including huge Hollywood players like Capra, who was ranked as a Major in the U.S. Signal corps and made many propaganda films for the U.S. Government. Star of the film James Stewart, was a bomber commander in Europe and flew many dangerous missions over Germany.

James Stewart receives a medal for bravery.
James Stewart being awarded a medal for bravery for his actions in the Second Waorld War.

Upon returning to Hollywood in 1945, Capra was “anxious” and “a bit frightened” at the prospect of returning to work to make a commercial feature film. Due to changes in world views, he questioned his abilities to recreate the old magic.

His experiences during the war years lead him to question his faith in the human race and the goodness of man. Had he portrayed events in his older films a little too naively? Was he wrong to believe that man is essentially good and that things will inevitably work out for the best in the end, if the cause is just, and the moral high ground is maintained? Irrepressibly upbeat and a fan of laughter, Capra would come to an equilibrium in his heart, which he channelled through the creation of It’s a Wonderful Life.

It is essentially a good-hearted fable, that inspires both tears and laughter. A series of order, followed by disorder and in turn followed by restoration of order, is one of the recurring themes throughout the film. The story champions the human spirit and our ongoing plight with the daily grind, living with the disappointment of having to watch our dreams slide away slowly, due to necessary as well as selfless sacrifices.

James Stewart plays George Bailey in It's a Wonderful Life (1946)
American actor James Stewart plays ‘everyman’ George Bailey in It’s A Wonderful Life (1946)

The central character George Bailey (played by James Stewart) is our typical everyman. A plucky, hard-working, middle-class American. His sights are set firmly on the top, as he dreams early on of travelling the globe and of a successful career as a civil engineer. His youthful plans are grandiose and yet still plausibly attainable given his intelligence, good character, general acumen and determination. However, as the film progresses, we see George have to relinquish one dream after another and make several sacrifices, for the good of those around him. He is of course, comforted somewhat by the love of a good woman.

Wonderfully played by Donna Reed; the character of Mary is smitten with George since childhood and becomes his high school sweetheart and ultimately his wife. Throughout the film she acts as his counsel, moral compass and muse. For each inauspicious event that unfolds before George, he has the love of another. A consolation most people will rightly settle for, at the end of a hard day.

Donna Reed and James Stewart in It's A Wonderful Life. (1946)
Donna Reed plays Mary in It’s A Wonderful Life (1946)

We see George measured against the other male figures in his life. For instance his father, a taciturn and good-hearted man who has worked all his life for little, but managed to support his family and live a blameless existence. There’s also the villain of the piece, the cantankerous and ruthless Mr. Potter, played by the magnificent Lionel Barrymore (great-Uncle of Drew Barrymore). In Potter, Capra feeds all his dissatisfaction with right-wing conservatism and the more selfish facets of the human heart. Potter is everything George stands against and ultimately, someone he must appear before, cap in hand, to beg for mercy.

There is also George’s best friend Sam Wainwright, who juxtaposed to George, seems to have all the luck and money in the world. Despite all his ‘would’ve been’ and ‘should’ve been’ moments, we see in George Bailey,  a “righteous dude” as Bill and Ted would say. There are also two incidental characters in the movie, a cop and a taxi driver named Bert and Ernie. Apparently there is much debate as to whether the Henson Workshop intended the tribute to It’s a Wonderful Life, in naming two of their flagship characters on Sesame Street.

Hard times for George and co. in It’s A Wonderful Life (1946).

Ultimately, George is confronted with a dire situation in which his buildings and loans company falls foul of his well-meaning but bumbling Uncle, who misplaces $8000 (which falls into the hands of the evil Potter) and is threatened with complete collapse. After returning home and taking it out on his wife and children, George does what any other down-on-his-luck American man would do in the face of such blues, he goes to the tavern to drown his sorrows. Realising that his life insurance policy is good for $15,000, George gets it into his head that he is worth more dead than he is alive. Having four children and a wife to provide for, George decides to throw himself from the bridge and into the river below.

James Stewart as George in It's A Wonderful Life (1946)
Geroge contemplates jumping from the bridge into the icy river below in It’s A Wonderful Life (1946)

But, thanks to an aspiring 1st class angel called Clarence Odbody (played by Henry Travers), George is rescued from his suicide attempt by proxy, in that Clarence throws himself into the river, causing George to react naturally and plunge in to save Clarence. Here the film takes a more fictitious hue, as Clarence shows George what life would’ve been like without him had he never existed.

The ensuing scenes remind us of the old Charles Dickens classic A Christmas Carol, where Ebenezer Scrooge is shown his past, present and future, in an attempt to awaken his true self and make a pathway for redemption. George Bailey is also given a similar lesson by supernatural forces, determined to ‘save his soul’, so to speak. Also a Christmas favourite, It’s a Wonderful Life reminds us of what it is to be fortunate enough to have the love of family and friends, and of the importance of sacrifice and selflessness.

James Stewart and Lionel Barrymore in It's A Wonderful Life (1946)
“I believe that’s my $8000 in your desk drawer!” Jimmy Stewart (George Bailey) & Lionel Barrymore (Mr. Potter) lock horns.

Technically the film has some unique moments, the use of freeze frame and close up shots treat us to a peek into the character’s souls. The special effects are as good as can be expected for a film of its age. Colour versions have been released over the years, however I believe it is best viewed in black and white. When I was a child, I thought that the whole world was in black and white before the invention of colour in the 1950’s. Some films benefit from this original presentation, as they play to our sense of nostalgia for a simpler and more innocent time.

It's A Wonderful Life cast (1946)
All’s well that ends well. The emotional conclusion to It’s A Wonderful Life (1946)

I believe that even the hardest heart, would fail to be secretly melted by the emotional ending to the film, wherein we see the local community rally together, to save George from disaster by contributing cash donations and well wishes. The children run to their father with open arms and a wealth of affection. His wife looks on lovingly, satisfied in her husband’s happiness. I personally had to fight back the tears, which I didn’t expect!

Sometimes the emotional feeling of happiness and sadness are the same feeling. Both have equal power to wring the heart out. The film hits the spot in this respect; although we will always know sacrifice, disappointment and struggling, we will always have love, empathy and kindness, if we are lucky enough to have friends and family. Love, awe, respect and veneration will fill your heart after seeing this film, and Walt Whitman knew how much it was a wonderful life. All those years before any of us were even born, he had the reverence to sing his prose across time, directly to Frank Capra’s heart and to ours in turn.

Did you enjoy this retrospective review of It’s A Wonderful Life?

You can read more of our reviews here.

Please join us on social media on FacebookInstagramTik Tok and Twitter. We really appreciate all the likes, shares, retweets etc., and we would love to hear from you and continue the wonderful celebration of all things cinema on these platforms.

If you love to watch videos on YouTube, then please subscribe to our channel here. There’s lots of fun and informative videos uploaded that we hope you will enjoy!

We have a passion for movies and aim to produce entertaining and informative movie-related content. It certainly is a lot of hard work, but we love films so much that it’s worth all the effort. We have to keep the lights on and make sure we have plenty of caffeine to keep all of the articles, videos and social media posts coming, so if you like our work, then please consider supporting us at Buy Me A Coffee here. You can also become a More Movies patron on Patreon here.

To help support us here at More Movies, we do use advertising in a few places, so we appreciate it if you do not use AdBlockers on our site, as this helps keep a few pennies trickling in. We also utilise affiliate links throughout the site, usually to help guide our readers to places to stream, rent or buy the movies we talk about. One of the biggest sources for movies online is Amazon Prime Video, where you can stream over 18,000 films. If you are interested in Prime and haven’t signed up yet, you can get a 30-day free trial via this affiliate link, which helps support us too.

Greg Fisher
Greg is a digital content creator, photographer, filmmaker and writer. You can follow him on Twitter and Instagram @theflyingartist